+1
Fixed

Shabbat Hanukkah maftir - only one prince

Josh Greenfield 2 years ago updated by Peggy Knox 4 weeks ago 3

The Hanukkah Torah reading for weekdays (per Ashkenazic custom outside of Israel) is two days of the princes bringing offerings from the section of Numbers 7 (e.g., on day 3 of Hanukkah we read of the prince who brought offerings on day 3), plus the prince who brought offerings on day 4).  On Shabbat of Hanukkah (when not also Rosh Hodesh) we read the regular Torah reading for 7 aliyot, and the maftir reading is just one prince, corresponding to that day of Hanukkah (e.g., if Shabbat is day 3 we read of the prince from day 3 only).  Hebcal.com right now is showing that the Shabbat of Hanukkah this year we read from Numbers 7:18-29, which is two princes:

https://www.hebcal.com/sedrot/vayeshev-20201212

I'm guessing the algorithm is just using the weekday Hanukkah custom to figure out what the Shabbat maftir reading should be, but that seems to be incorrect.  For the source of the Hanukkah reading, you can check Shulkhan Aruch OH 684:2 (note 6 in the Mishnah Berurah specifies only one prince in the maftir).

+1

Hi Josh, thanks for using Hebcal, and thanks for this bug report.


You are correct, and we've fixed the bug in our Torah Readings so the Shabbat Chanukah maftir algorithm isn't blindly assuming that it's the entire weekday reading. On the days where it should only be the first 6 p'sukim (as it was 2 years ago when you posted this bug report), it now shows the correct reasding.

Our sincere apologies for the lateness of this reply.

Michael thannk you so much fir all you do and let us know tours hands are inmpaied.  It hels as mine or impaired and painful.  i aologize fir th ty0s byut after five timesk I give u.  Manchester is right next door to Hartford nd has 4zi codes.  It is in artford County.  I live in torrington, 

CT the beginning of the northwest cornber of the state in Litchfield 

County.  My zip0 is 06790.

 Hartford being so close it ould robbly be the most accurate. 0robably gve you the most accurrate and if you want the zip cods, let me know, I'll email them to you.  Manchester is next door to hard--mYbe one or two towns, but probably nor more than 15 min unless it's communter time.  I'm about 35 minutes from Hartfpord.  Sprng, Ma os about a half hour from Manchester, maybe a litte more. Its about an hor via the backroads.  G-d s not going to go banas if ytheuyare not theexact minute.  

the are lucky they can light the cndles.  Im on oxygen Icanh't and vbattery candles don't do anything for me.   use to look so forward to lighting the 

shabbos candles.  I wasn't always on time but I got as close as i clda-ologozedtp 

gd if I was late.  i felt no recrimination from it.  I reallky dson't understand this whooe conversation and about things being so -erfect.  Michael you do a great job nd Iit means so uch to me.  sorry OIm not going t go bac and do the corrections and slling.  I'm sure you can understad what you to.  Let me know if you need the zi-p codes.   do have zip code boode, though dsome of the back pages are missing so 

wyoming my be ;ess afew in the boo0k.  Let me knw if you need any.

shalom{Peggy J. knox